| Emma Parks | Marquette University | 2025 |
| Julia Oster | Colgate University | 2025 |
| Belle Groomes | University of San Diego | 2025 |
| Ella Iriarte | Duquesne University | 2024 |
| Izzy Shank | Walsh University | 2024 |
| Clare O'Malley | Wittenberg University | 2024 |
| Gracelyn Skupski | University of Mount Union | 2024 |
| Anna Mihacevich | University of Mount Union | 2024 |
| Sam Young | Ashland University | 2024 |
| Sydney Waller | Samford University | 2024 |
| Emma McCartney | Northern Illinois University | 2024 |
| Alexa Strandberg | University of South Alabama | 2024 |
| Avery Anders | Bowling Green State University | 2024 |
| Natalie Robinson | Rutgers University | 2024 |
| Hannah Pattie | Campbell University | 2024 |
| Julia Sprecher | Louisiana State University - Beach | 2024 |
| Laura Fuehrer | University of Maryland Baltimore County | 2024 |
| Adalynn Ginley | Marshall University | 2023 |
| Alayna Tessena | University of Northern Colorado | 2023 |
| Alli Bedrick | Middle Tennessee State University | 2023 |
| Alyssa Krause | Mercyhurst University | 2023 |
| Avery Krause | Ohio Wesleyan University | 2023 |
| Breanna Ginley | Marshall University | 2023 |
| Caroline Jurevicius | University of Nebraska | 2023 |
| Chloe Brown | University at Buffalo | 2023 |
| Jada Colvin | Ohio Wesleyan University | 2023 |
| Kallan Hrics | John Carroll University | 2023 |
| Keegan Trainor | Denison University | 2023 |
| Kira Holland | Indiana State University | 2023 |
| Laney Klika | Wofford College | 2023 |
| Lauren Janosy | UNC Greensboro | 2023 |
| Lauren Yacobucci | Wright State University | 2023 |
| Makenzie Schellenberger | Otterbein University | 2023 |
| Meg Gannon | Colorado College | 2023 |
| Melissa Hansen | University of Mount Union | 2023 |
| Natalie Glowe | John Carroll University | 2023 |
| Natalie Zemba | Fairmont State University | 2023 |
| Nia Hall | Cleveland State University | 2023 |
| Sophia Anghilante | Indiana State University | 2023 |
| Sydney Wake | Gannon University | 2023 |
| Abbey Havrilla | Mercer University | 2022 |
| Anna Freeman | Washington University | 2022 |
| Annika Nichols | Malone University | 2022 |
| Cadence Shea | University of North Carolina | 2022 |
| Dakota Drenth | Otterbein University | 2022 |
| Ella Rogers | Baldwin Wallace University | 2022 |
| Elle McLoughlin | Eastern Michigan University | 2022 |
| Emma Shupp | John Carroll University | 2022 |
| Hanna Wilson | Duquesne Univeristy | 2022 |
| Iyanna (Moosh) Battle | Florida Gulf Coast University | 2022 |
| Jess Wilson | Eastern Michigan University | 2022 |
| Josie Skinn | Fairmont State University | 2022 |
| Julia Shaw | Clarion University | 2022 |
| Kathryn Randorf | Northwestern University | 2022 |
| Kirsten Barrett | Georgia Southern University | 2022 |
| Mia Soerensen | University of Texas San Antonio | 2022 |
| Morgan Rogers | Otterbein University | 2022 |
| Mya Sopata | University of North Florida | 2022 |
| Olivia Jurcevic | Otterbein University | 2022 |
| Sabrina Gremm | Eastern Michigan University | 2022 |
| Sammie Dibease | Walsh University | 2022 |
| Abby Walker | University of Cincinnati | 2021 |
| Emma Walker | Cleveland State University | 2021 |
| Emmy Klika | University of Pittsburgh | 2021 |
| Hanna Bissler | University of Miami/University of South Carolina | 2021 |
| Jen Sivak | Bucknell University | 2021 |
| Joy Banks | Northern Kentucky University | 2021 |
| Kamiah Gibson | West Virginia University/The Ohio State University | 2021 |
| Kate Mihacevich | Nova Southeastern University | 2021 |
| Maddy Hooper | Palm Beach Atlantic University/Nova Southeastern University | 2021 |
| Madison Olinger | Cleveland State University | 2021 |
| Madison Quirino | Cleveland State University | 2021 |
| Missy Sterkel | Belmont University | 2021 |
| Abby Bednar | Southern Indiana University | 2020 |
| Alana Stevens | Lake Erie College | 2020 |
| Alexis Mettille | Bowling Green University | 2020 |
| Amelia Purdue | Kent State University | 2020 |
| Annie Monaco | Robert Morris University | 2020 |
| Bridget Burrus | Heidelberg University | 2020 |
| Ella Mihacevich | Northern Illinois University | 2020 |
| Katy Yopko | Northern Kentucky University | 2020 |
| Lourdes Meyer | Purdue University | 2020 |
| Maddie Stayer | Southern Mississippi University | 2020 |
| Maddy Bilinovic | Penn State Univeristy | 2020 |
| Madeline Swentor | University of South Carolina | 2020 |
| Madison McCoy | Otterbein University | 2020 |
| Meg Merril | Wake Forest University | 2020 |
| Sabrina Malcolm | The College of William & Mary | 2020 |
| Samantha Csire | University of Maryland | 2020 |
| Samantha Ruggles | Providence College | 2020 |
| Samantha Snow | Cleveland State University | 2020 |
| Adria Powell | The Ohio State University/Clemson University | 2019 |
| Annie Borah | Mercyhurst University | 2019 |
| Ashley Dwyer | Loyola University Maryland | 2019 |
| Ava Rauser | Harvard University | 2019 |
| Cecy Guye | Loyola University Maryland | 2019 |
| Dana Dull | Eckerd College | 2019 |
| Eliza Richardson | Ohio Wesleyan University | 2019 |
| Gabby Bailey | Penn State University | 2019 |
| Hailey Poling | Duquesne Univeristy | 2019 |
| JoAnna Chang | Cornell University | 2019 |
| Kacie Evans | University of Georgia | 2019 |
| Kayla Jarosz | Malone University | 2019 |
| Kelly Lynch | California University of Pennsylvania | 2019 |
| Kiana Mack | University of Alabama Birmingham | 2019 |
| Kirsten Badowski | UNC Wilmington | 2019 |
| Megan Alders | Wright State University | 2019 |
| Megan Brzozowski | Fordham University | 2019 |
| Morgan Copley | Kent State University | 2019 |
| Olivia Young | Wittenberg University | 2019 |
| Rachael Crucis | Purdue University - Fort Wayne | 2019 |
| Sam Fillar | Ohio Wesleyan University | 2019 |
| Annalyse Kitsberger | Davidson University | 2018 |
| Cacey Cook | Slippery Rock University | 2018 |
| Chase Cole | Wheeling Jesuit University | 2018 |
| Claire Yohann | Emory University | 2018 |
| Emily Schillinger | Fairfield University | 2018 |
| Ila Angermeier | Ohio University | 2018 |
| Jess Barrett | St. Francis University | 2018 |
| Khala Cameron | Coppin State University | 2018 |
| Kimmy Sweeney | St. Francis University | 2018 |
| Madison Kasper | Mercyhurst University | 2018 |
| Morgan Goodwin | Alabama A&M University | 2018 |
| Sally Sterkel | Edinboro University | 2018 |
| Shannon Williams | University of Cincinnati | 2018 |
| Zoe Gadomski | Mercyhurst University | 2018 |
| Alena Madar | Cornell University | 2017 |
| Alex Spencer | University of Virginia | 2017 |
| Amelia Richardson | Ohio Wesleyan University | 2017 |
| Ammaarah Williams | Cleveland State University | 2017 |
| Ashley Kozer | Texas Christian University/University of Cincinnati | 2017 |
| Erinn Kahoe | Slippery Rock University | 2017 |
| Gabby Wine | Ursuline College | 2017 |
| Jessica Gavlak | Capital University | 2017 |
| Julie Kruse | Walsh University | 2017 |
| Katie Konopka | Ohio Wesleyan University | 2017 |
| Madison Cruzado | Notre Dame University | 2017 |
| Maggie Nedoma | Ohio University | 2017 |
| Margaux Thompson | Youngstown State | 2017 |
| Maya Eller | University of Cincinnati | 2017 |
| McKinley Smith | Ashland University | 2017 |
| Megan Utlak | Michigan Tech | 2017 |
| Viktoria Farian | Seton Hill University | 2017 |
| Aleah Stauffer | Wheeling Jesuit University | 2016 |
| Alex Tubbs | Denison University | 2016 |
| Allyson Smith | Baldwin Wallace University | 2016 |
| Ashley Makruski | Kent State University | 2016 |
| Brooke Bailey | The Ohio State University/Clemson University | 2016 |
| Chloe Stile | Washington University | 2016 |
| Justine Coffman | Walsh University | 2016 |
| Zoe Rivet | Slippery Rock University | 2016 |
| Emily Duke | Bethany College | 2015 |
| Jordan Diels | Baldwin Wallace University | 2015 |
| Shae Bauchens | Cornell University | 2015 |
| Abby Detering | University of Florida | 2014 |
| Cierra Koons | Eastern Kentucky University | 2014 |
| Cortnee Bowser | University of Cincinnati | 2014 |
| Courtney Bowman | University of New Hampshire | 2014 |
| Emily Marcinowski | St. Francis University | 2014 |
| Jamie Kosiorek | Ohio University | 2014 |
| Jenna Veres | St. Francis University | 2014 |
| Jessica Janota | University of Iowa | 2014 |
| Kristen Mummey | College of Charleston | 2014 |
| Kyra Coundourides | Virginia Tech/Temple University | 2014 |
| Lauren Bakaitis | University of Toledo | 2014 |
| Macie Pifer | University of Cincinnati | 2014 |
| Mackenzie Harrison | Fairmont State University | 2014 |
| Meredith Ruetty | Fairmont State University | 2014 |
| Molly Davet | Duquesne Univeristy | 2014 |
| Sarah Peterson | Indiana State University | 2014 |
| Stephanie Bindernagel | Indiana State University | 2014 |
| Arielle Sanders | Bethany College | 2013 |
| Ashley Watson | College of Charleston | 2013 |
| Hannah Tyburski | Oberlin College | 2013 |
| Jackie Ritt | John Carroll University | 2013 |
| Julie Colianni | Case Western Reserve University | 2013 |
| Kenya Moyers | Case Western Reserve University | 2013 |
| Kristi Tekavec | Florida Atlantic University | 2013 |
| Lauren Beck | Gannon University | 2013 |
| Lauren Youngblood | Loyola University Maryland | 2013 |
| Morgan Toman | Notre Dame College | 2013 |
| Paige Hill | Miami University (Ohio) | 2013 |
| Ali Rogers | Capital University | 2012 |
| Arielle Parente | Rochester Institute of Technology | 2012 |
| Chelsey Tekavec | Valparaiso University | 2012 |
| Courtney Grdina | Washington & Jefferson College | 2012 |
| Dani Witri | Case Western Reserve University | 2012 |
| Kaitlyn Witsaman | Fairmont State University | 2012 |
| Katherine Zito | Wittenberg University | 2012 |
| Kelsey Deils | University of Mount Union | 2012 |
| Kennedy Clyde | Marietta College | 2012 |
| Kristen Smith | Slippery Rock University | 2012 |
| Mallory Gustincic | Lake Erie College | 2012 |
| Marche Johnson | Cleveland State University | 2012 |
| Rachel Jones | Palm Beach Atlantic | 2012 |
| Shayna Hunt | Morgan State University | 2012 |
| Abbey Cvelbar | Eastern Kentucky University | 2011 |
| Alexis Plagens | Eastern Kentucky University | 2011 |
| Arielle Love | Duquesne Univeristy | 2011 |
| Callie Durdel | Hiedelberg College | 2011 |
| Kara Schiffer | Loyola University Maryland | 2011 |
| Kristin Primozic | Elmhurst College | 2011 |
| Makenzie Wickert | Southern Illinois University | 2011 |
| Melissa Wichie | Bluffton University | 2011 |
| Regina Zyle | Hiram College | 2011 |
| Shirjoma Jacobs | Hiram College | 2011 |
| Brittney Jackson | Grand Valley State University | 2010 |
| Charlotte Sykora | John Carroll University | 2010 |
| Colleen Bonacci | Baldwin Wallace University | 2010 |
| Jennifer Mohney | Wheeling Jesuit University | 2010 |
| Mary Katherine Bastulli | John Carroll University | 2010 |
| Megan Romocean | Westminster College | 2010 |
| Ally Jenkins | Marietta College | 2009 |
| Ashley Venable | Hiram College | 2009 |
| Dana Coleman | Case Western Reserve University | 2009 |
| Erin Webster | The College of Wooster | 2009 |
| Heather Kuch | Ohio Wesleyan University | 2009 |
| Katie Opfer | Otterbein University | 2009 |
| Mary Walter | Lake Erie College | 2009 |
| Rebecca Palivoda | Baldwin Wallace University | 2009 |
| Sarah Campbell | Thiel College | 2009 |
